Return Home Members Area Experts Area The best AskMe alternative!Answerway.com - You Have Questions? We have Answers! Answerway Information Contact Us Online Help
 Sunday 19th May 2024 09:31:03 PM


 

Username:

Password:

or
Join Now!

 

Home/Government/Politics

Forum Ask A Question   Question Board   FAQs Search
Return to Question Board

Question Details Asked By Asked On
COMPARISON: HANK1 02/09/07


    Are the World War II kamikaze pilots equivalent to the suicide bombers in Iraq and elsewhere? Some weird stuff, huh?

    HANK

      Clarification/Follow-up by tomder55 on 02/09/07 3:38 pm:
      I don't see a pyshcological comparison at all. A kamikaze was heroic . A homicide bomber performs cowardly acts against innocent civilians . He is given a false promise of a reward for his act . It is not courageous ;it is not selfless.

      What is a sucicide mission in military terms ? Joshua Chamberlain leading 300 tired troops of the 20th Maine ,who were out of ammo ,in a bayonet charge down Little Round Top during the battle of Gettysburg is one .

      During the battle Gen Winfield Scott Hancock found a gap in the Union Center that the Confederates were poised to exploit . He needed to quickly plug the gap . To make time he ordered 262 men of the 1 Minnesota to charge a Confederate postion of 1600 men. 47 returned ;but they gave the General time to plug the gap. That was a suicide mission worthy of a soldier.

      In a desperate move to destroy the Union position on the 3rd day of the battle General Lee sacrificed the entire Pickett corp. Their charge was a suicide mission that was honorable .

      I see no heroism in homicide bombers at all.

 
Summary of Answers Received Answered On Answered By Average Rating
1. The suicide bombers are scarier. You don't know they are...
02/09/07 captainoutrageousExcellent or Above Average Answer
2. not really . The kamikaze attacked military targets ..not w...
02/09/07 tomder55Excellent or Above Average Answer
3. Yes and no. There are certain similarities between the kami...
02/09/07 ETWolverineExcellent or Above Average Answer
4. I'd say equating - as tom accurately calls them - "%^@...
02/09/07 ItsdbExcellent or Above Average Answer
5. Yes, they are. They both have the same kind of mix of po...
02/09/07 drgadeExcellent or Above Average Answer
Your Options
    Additional Options are only visible when you login! !

viewq   © Copyright 2002-2008 Answerway.org. All rights reserved. User Guidelines. Expert Guidelines.
Privacy Policy. Terms of Use.   Make Us Your Homepage
. Bookmark Answerway.